The True Cost of a Bad Hire
For any business, hiring the right talent is a pivotal decision. A good hire can propel a company forward, while a bad one can have far-reaching consequences that go beyond just financial losses.
A "bad hire" commonly refers to an organisation hiring an individual who turns out to be a poor fit for the job or the company. This typically happens when the hired employee does not meet the expectations and requirements of the position they were hired for, and their performance and behaviour in the workplace fall significantly short of what was anticipated.
It's also essential to recognise that the term "bad hire" isn't a reflection of the individual's character; rather, it signifies a mismatch between the employee's skills, qualities, or performance and the job's requirements and the organisation's needs.
Hiring the wrong person for a job is a more common occurrence than one might assume. According to an article piece from SCOOP, 98% of New Zealand hiring managers have hired an employee who did not meet expectations, primarily because of a mismatch of skills (49%), the candidate not keeping commitments (37%) or underqualified candidates (35%).
In this blog, we'll explore the DIRECT and INDIRECT costs of a bad hire and how a recruitment agency like Tech 5 conducts a comprehensive pre-employment process to help mitigate these risks.
Direct Costs of a Bad Hire
Recruitment Costs
The process of recruiting a new employee involves advertising, screening, interviewing, and onboarding. When a bad hire is made, these costs go to waste, as the candidate is ultimately not a good fit for the position.
Training Expenses
Companies invest significant resources in training new employees. If a bad hire doesn't meet expectations or leaves shortly after being hired, all training costs are essentially lost.
Salary and Benefits
The salary and benefits provided to the bad hire represent a direct financial loss. Not only does the company pay for unproductive work, but the money could have been invested in a more suitable employee.
Legal Fees
Handling the departure of a bad hire can be both time-consuming and costly, especially when legal proceedings come into play.
Indirect Costs of a Bad Hire
Decreased Productivity
A bad hire often leads to decreased team productivity and morale. Co-workers may have to pick up the slack, leading to increased stress and potential burnout.
Employee Turnover
Bad hires can have a domino effect, leading to the departure of more skilled and capable employees who are frustrated with the situation. High employee turnover adds to the company's recruitment costs and reduces overall stability.
Damaged Reputation
A bad hire can harm a company's reputation, both internally and externally. It can lead to negative employee reviews and even deter potential clients or customers.
How Tech 5 Recruitment Mitigates the Risks
Skills Assessment
We assess candidates' skills thoroughly to ensure they possess the necessary competencies for the job. This reduces the chances of hiring someone unqualified for the position.
Reference Checks
We conduct thorough reference checks to verify a candidate's work history and qualifications, helping to prevent dishonest or unqualified hires.
Criminal History Checks
To ensure the safety and security of the workplace, Tech 5 conducts criminal history checks on potential candidates.
Health and Safety Training
In positions where safety is paramount, Tech 5 provides health and safety training to candidates, ensuring they are prepared for the specific requirements of the role.
Cultural Fit Assessment
Tech 5 goes beyond just assessing skills and qualifications. We also evaluate a candidate's cultural fit with the company to reduce the chances of hiring someone who doesn't align with the organisation's values and goals.
Contingent Workforce
Tech 5 also specialises in providing a flexible/project-based workforce. Businesses that utilise a contingent workforce have the flexibility to adapt to changing demands, control costs, and access specific skills as needed without committing to long-term employment contracts.
In conclusion, the costs associated with a bad hire extend well beyond the initial recruitment and training expenses. They encompass decreased productivity, damaged reputation, and even employee turnover.
Tech 5 Recruitment understands the significance of minimising these costs through a comprehensive pre-employment process that includes skills assessment, reference checks, criminal history checks, health and safety training and utilising a contingent workforce.
By partnering with a recruitment agency that prioritises these factors, companies can significantly reduce the risks associated with bad hires and ultimately build a stronger, more productive team.
To know more about Our Services, visit our website here or get in touch with one of our Consultants.








